Livingston was last seen in downtown Indianapolis, Indiana on August 6, 1993. He has never been heard from again. Authorities believe he was a victim of the serial killer Herbert Richard "Herb" Baumeister, who was responsible for the deaths of many young men in the Indianapolis area during the 1990s. A photo of Baumeister is posted below this case summary. He shot himself in Port Huron, Ontario in June 1996, just as the police were preparing to arrest him. He left a note blaming his suicide on business troubles and his failing marriage, and did not mention the murders. A search of his eighteen-acre property turned up the burned skeletal remains of approximately eleven individuals, only four of whom have been identified.

Livingston was a homosexual man in his twenties, which fits the profile of Baumeister's victims. His body was not one of those found on the serial killer's property, however, and his case remains unsolved.

Above: Herb Baumeister