Details of Disappearance Pflum left from her family's residence in Connersville, Indiana on March 28, 1986. She planned to retrieve her purse, which she believed she left at a party the previous evening. She asked multiple friends as well as her sister to accompany her to the site of the party, some farmland, but none of them could go so she decided to go there alone.
According to the tenant of the farm where the party was held, Pflum never arrived arrived at her destination, although a friend reportedly saw her at 2:00 p.m. at a Fashion Bug store on 30th Street. She didn't have any identification when she left home, or the carrying case or cleaning solution for her contact lenses. She has never been heard from again.
The following day, a farmer from Glenwood, Indiana reported that Pflum's cream-colored 1981 Buick Regal, which was registered to her parents, had been locked and abandoned alongside Tower Road, a rural gravel road east of Glenwood, since between 12:30 and 1:15 p.m. the day she went missing. This spot was all the way across the county from where she lived, and three miles from the party site; her family can't think of a reason why she would have gone there. There were no indications of a struggle at the scene.
In July 2020, Shawn M. McClung was arrested and charged with voluntary manslaughter in Pflum's presumed death. The charge indicates authorities believe McClung killed Pflum in the heat of the moment, without premeditation and without using a deadly weapon. He was Pflum's ex-boyfriend and had previously claimed Pflum was still alive, but had recently admitted he had killed her in March 1986. A photo of McClung is posted with this case summary.
At the time of McClung's confession, he was suffering from a terminal illness. He died in September 2020 at the of 56, just months after he was charged in Pflum's case and before he could face trial.
Pflum was a senior at Connersville High School at the time of her disappearance; she was involved with volleyball, basketball, softball and track, and was a member of the National Honor Society. She had already been accepted to Miami University in Ohio, where she planned to major in microbiology and hoped to get a track scholarship.
Authorities have never recovered Pflum's body, but foul play is suspected in her case due to the circumstances involved.
- Fayette County Sheriff's Department
Updated 8 times since October 12, 2004. Last updated September 30, 2020; details of disappearance updated.