Edward Lee Vannatter Jr.

Vannatter, circa 2003; John Caputo in 2012

  • Missing Since 10/01/2003
  • Missing From Eastlake, Ohio
  • Classification Endangered Missing
  • Sex Male
  • Race White
  • Date of Birth 07/04/1971 (52)
  • Age 32 years old
  • Height and Weight 5'5, 160 pounds
  • Clothing/Jewelry Description Possibly blue jeans, a t-shirt and a gray pullover sweatshirt.
  • Medical Conditions Vannatter is addicted to methamphetamine.
  • Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian male. Brown hair, brown eyes. Vannatter's nickname is Eddie.

Details of Disappearance

Vannatter was last seen in early October 2003. He was living with a roommate, John Caputo, in a rental home on east 345th Street in Eastlake, Ohio. A photograph of him s posted with this case summary.

Caputo said Vannatter came home with a man named Mark, whom Caputo hadn't met before, and the two men had drugs and drug paraphernalia. Mark's last name is unknown.

Caputo was on probation and didn't want drugs in the house. There was a minor physical altercation between the three men, and Vannatter and Mark left the residence. Vannatter has never been heard from again.

Vannatter's family was unconcerned by his absence at first. He had dropped out of sight before for as long as a month at at time due to his drug addiction, and his relatives believed he was probably staying with friends temporarily.

When Thanksgiving came and went without his loved ones hearing from him, his mother and stepfather reported him missing. His mother stated it would be uncharacteristic of him to run off with someone he'd just met.

After Vannatter's disappearance, Caputo quickly disposed of all his belongings; he later said he'd done it because he was angry at Vannatter. Police believe Caputo may know more about Vannatter's disappearance than he's disclosed, but no suspects have been named in the case.

In 2012, Caputo called Vannatter's mother and left a message on her machine saying he was going to commit suicide and wanted her to know he had had nothing to do with her son's disappearance.

Caputo did not, in fact, take his life; instead, a week later, he turned himself into the police to face charges that he had robbed four banks in Lake County, Ohio. He is still incarcerated for that.

Captuo has a lengthy criminal record for crimes including burglary, kidnapping, theft, stalking, receiving stolen property, and drug and weapons offenses. Not long after Vannatter disappeared, he told his ex-wife he'd committed a crime that had no statute of limitations.

He has ties to West Virginia and investigators think he could have disposed of Vannatter's body there; he had once said West Virginia would be a good place to hide a body. At one point, Caputo tried to negotiate through his attorney to lead police to Vannatter's remains, but the deal never went through.

Vannatter's family describes him as a good-hearted man who loved animals and children. Foul play is suspected in his disappearance; it remains unsolved.

Investigating Agency

  • Lake County Sheriff's Office
  • 440-350-5521
  • 440-350-5533

Updated 5 times since October 12, 2004. Last updated November 9, 2017; details of disappearance updated.